No Apologies: Remembering Kurt Cobain
1 April 2004 - Well, folks. It's been 10 years since Kurt Cobain ended his own life. For some reason, even before I started publishing the Herald, when I was just putting out a photocopied ‘zine, I wanted to have an “Ode to Kurt" feature where various people would write about what the grunge rocker meant to them.
Now that a Best-of-Nirvana CD is hitting stores, this
is as good a time as any. So here goes:
It's deadline time, so I'm too busy (and lazy) to look up exact dates
for what record was released when, etc. But you know what? Who cares. This is
all about people's memories (even incorrect ones) of the early ‘90's
and what Kurt meant to them. Here are some memories from me:
It was the fall of 1991 and I had just turned 26 a couple of months earlier.
I had been in California for 6 years now, and was feeling a bit of malaise.
In a way it was worse than the malaise I felt as a teenager back in New York.
At
least then, in 1981, I had a feeling that it was just temporary, that I was
just serving time, that things were going to be great once I graduated high
school
and got to leave the confines of my Long Island town and see the world. Shangri-la,
the 72 virgins, the whole 9 yards. Maybe I would move somewhere far away and
try something new. You think that when you graduate high school and the world
starts to treat you like an adult, it will be great. And then it happens and
it is.
But as those wonderful college years (in my case nearly seven) came to a close, so did many other things. Like your feeling of supreme confidence. Confidence? Hell, make that invincibility. Maybe you never had it, but I was arrogant enough to, and man, what a great feeling it was. Here I was in ‘91: a college graduate (okay, it was a bullshit degree in Art, but it was from San Jose State; a good school for art, and hey it was still a 4 year degree) who had traveled around Europe upon graduation, worked many interesting jobs, interned in the Hollywood casting office that did the work for “Seinfeld", and was a self-sufficient (though broke) adult. So why was it that I had such little confidence compared to when I was 20 and had just moved to the Bay Area and thought I was hot shit even though I did nothing but attend the community college in San Mateo and drove around in a gas-guzzling 1977 Camaro?
The malaise I felt in ‘81 was due to not being able to get to the party fast enough. The malaise I felt 10 years later was of being hung over and knowing that the party was over, and that there will never be another party like it. That all those hopes and dreams I had in high school and college were unrealistic and weren't going to come true. That those friends I had, who I thought would always be there for me, were now my enemies. That life was a LOT more complicated than I thought it was. That I couldn't trust anybody.
Pretty grim thoughts, eh? Well, regardless of them, they didn't drive me to end it all like Kurt did. I can't speak for Nirvana's front man, but it really boils down to how you start examining it (or re-examining it):
The party's over? At least I went and had a great time. My dreams were unrealistic and weren't going to come true? Well, if that's the case I shouldn't waste my time with them and instead come up with more realistic ones that may come true. That a lot of friends turned out to be duds? Then it's a good thing I found out in my 20's instead of my 40's and didn't count on them for anything. Besides, I've got good memories of when they were cool and nothing would piss them off more than them knowing I'm deriving enjoyment from them. Also, a lot of people I thought were merely acquaintances turned out to be good friends, so it works both ways. That life is a LOT more complicated than I thought it was? Good. It keeps things interesting. That I couldn't trust anybody? That just makes me more self-sufficient.
I may come across like Tony Robbins now, but during that Malaise II period, Kurt and Nirvana wrote songs about angst, alienation, and depression that really hit home for me (plus it had a great beat and you could dance to it). Live 105 pollutes the airwaves with noisy, soul-less, god awful post-grunge shit now, but ten years ago it was like a rebirth of listening to the “Modern Rock" of my adolescence. Sure -- Nirvana, Smashing Pumpkins, and Green Day may not have been as good as The Clash, The Police, or U2 -- but they were pretty darn good.
Hey, they were good enough.
Gene Mahoney
Editor and Publisher
San Francisco Herald
The biggest change in my life, resulting from the grunge
movement is that I stopped wearing plaid shirts. In high school I loved the
plaid shirt. It helped
me survive.
I wore one almost every day.
Before I discovered the joys of the plaid shirt
I suffered. School was boring and I would get an erection during every single
one of my classes, usually
toward the end of the period, right before the bell.
I limped between classes.
A binder, near my zipper, helped me hide myself.
Around my junior year I found that if I tied a long sleeve shirt around my
waist, the
sleeves would sort of cover my bulge. When it got cold I could untie my shirt
and wear it and that would hide me too.
Sometime in the late 80's or 90's
or something, grunge got popular. Everyone started wearing plaid over shirts.
They were being sold in expensive
catalogs for expensive prices. Suddenly a wave of fashion overtook me, and
I looked like I was trying to be trendy.
Sometime later, the lead singer, for
the musical leader of the grunge movement, killed himself. His wife, now a
widow, got popular with her own CD.
Now, on the anniversary of a suicide, the media celebrates the repackaging
of a marketing campaign that forced me to stop wearing plaid. Every time I
hear
grunge music I think about my erections.
Shannon Wheeler
Cartoonist
www.TMCM.com
Mick LaSalle
SF Chronicle film critic
Mary Cary
Former Singer for
Electric Peach
MaryCary.com
I remember when “Smells Like Teen Spirit" debuted as a ‘Buzz Bin' clip on MTV. I thought, “Good song…too bad these guys'll never get anywhere." The music industry just seemed so hopeless at the time, so oriented toward trivial pop acts like Poison and Warrant. No way was a real band gonna cut through the process and actually hit the Big-time. And yet, thankfully,
Nirvana did it. For a brief moment, it seemed like the corrupt regime was being overthrown. It didn't last long.
I don't think Nirvana could burst through now. The industry has changed drastically, in ways that prevent struggling artists from getting exposure. MTV rarely shows music videos anymore. The videos it does play are of prefabricated boy-band and girl-band acts. Same with radio. Because a few corporations, like ClearChannel, have bought all the promotion, booking, and marketing arms, they can dictate the content and style of what receives publicity, promotion, distribution, and airplay.
The industry learned well from Kurt Cobain. They won't take a chance on independent artists anymore. Much better to go the safe route. Sell product that has a proven track record. Assemble an accessible, harmless package for cost X and sell it for price Y. Look at Britney Spears, N'Sync, Christina Aguilera. Every aspect of their wardrobe, song selection, promotion, and performance is dictated by a well-funded machine. That machine wants malleable young product with no experience and no ideas. It thrives on artists who can't think for themselves, that will do as told in order to realize full investment potential. Doesn't leave much room for music. But music comes in fourth behind explicit videos, posters, and T-shirts.
Kurt Cobain represented a brief Fuck You to this machine that actually made it through. Hopefully it'll happen again.
I once had the chance to talk with one of the major figures of the Sixties, one of the main characters profiled in Tom Wolfe's ‘Electric Kool Aid Acid Test.' This fellow had been intimately associated with psychedelia, rock ‘n roll, and the Counterculture. We happened to talk about rock music and began to discuss Kurt Cobain. This famed Sixties fellow sneered at Cobain, calling him “insipid" and “an idiot." I told him how strongly I disagreed, at which point he commented that Cobain's music was “garbage." What I found most interesting, though, was that the guy didn't have the slightest idea why Cobain had succeeded. This Sixties figure had his money and his house and his Generation X children, but he had no awareness of single-parent homes, mass divorce, children of alcoholics, stabbings in schools, shootings in school, all the things that his Sixties generation had wrought. For me, one glance at Cobain, one listen to him speaking to a reporter, and I felt a kinship. I knew he'd been through the same grief as the rest of us. He was pissed-off. That anger is what scared the hell out of the Sixties fellow.
Steven Capozzola
Herald columnist
scap70@hotmail.com
Just coincidently, during the onset of grunge and the prevalence of Seattle-based bands such as Nirvana, Mudhoney and Alice in Chains, I was living in Manchester, England.
Now Manchester and the grunge mecca have one major similarity ……RAIN.
Foul weather that forces one to stay indoors, green and gray. However, sometimes through this internment a great creativity can be born, as it was in Seattle in the early 90's manifesting itself as grunge music. I should have easily identified with the renaissance of this rock style, as anti-pop, anti-fashion, and anti-commercialism were a welcome relief after the 80's scenes. I should have identified with the Kurt Cobain, only a few months older than me, vocalizing the torment of displaced generation X. At the time I even had a musician boyfriend and he too was releasing his frustrations and emotional anguish through his guitar, just like Kurt. Don't get me wrong, I had respect for grunge as a musical style, “Smells Like Teen Spirit" became my Sunday morning wake up music! But unlike others around me, I couldn't make it a life style. Maybe it was all those flannel shirts, ripped denim or layers of cheap black t-shirts turned gray. Maybe it was that I liked to wash my hair. Maybe my heart was still in the 80's with New Order and Cabaret Voltaire, who knows! However, grunge music certainly did unite a generation. Having been there and amongst the scene I can say one thing for sure. The myth that grunge musicians and followers alike didn't care about anything or anybody was ironically dispelled by the fact that they did care. They cared about music.
Sandy Dunn
Ubiquitous Aussie
I remember seeing that trippy video for “Smells Like Teen Spirit" and thinking it was kind of cool. Wondered if Kurt had ever used a comb. Then Weird Al Yankovic did that hilarious parody - that ruled!
I had just moved to New York from LA and was busy putting together my pre-Lilith Fair type band, LIFE ON MARS, that lost any chance in hell to get heard once NIRVANA and the grunge era took over. No one cared about female fronted bands/solo artists after that. Seattle and flannel, that was the deal, baby...
Kimberlye Gold
Herald columnist/ songwriter
I first heard Nirvana in New York at my friend Julie's apartment and the music totally suited the mood of my experience in NYC at that time. I think the year was 1992 and “Teen Spirit" just came out. Julie always had the newest hip music. Her sister Janet and I were in a band together in college and now Janet drums for a hip riot girl-ish band in Portland. My current band Cleve-Land rips off chord for chord the chorus for “Rape me" in one of our songs. We'll never be hip or famous but that suits me just fine.
Karen
Roze
Owner/Tattoo artist
Sacred Rose Tattoo
Starchild
Famous libertarian
Kimberlye Gold
Herald columnist
Ace Backwords
Cartoonist/Author
Supposedly she was the “new", yet irreplaceable, Tracy Lords. It was apparent in her despondent and shaky videos that she was both a heroin and cocaine addict, making it far less sensual than the movie producers had hoped. She couldn't articulate anymore and was completely catatonic, (like that mattered in porn), but it was obvious the pain she was in and the severity of her addictions. In interviews, she didn't seem to deny this. Kurt, on the other hand, went back and forth changing his story, especially once in rehab, which is completely understandable… he wanted out!
I remember reading
about how Savannah had, soon after making a fairly decent amount of films,
shot herself in the head. She had done so many drugs the night
of her suicide. She got in a car accident, somehow drove herself home, and
upon arriving, cried to the ‘blitzed hair band members' she was
staying with at the time to help her, and how she was ‘scarred for life
and her career was over.' She was no longer marketable. Yet they did
nothing to help her. I even heard they laughed at her whining, and told her
to drive herself to the E.R. with bloody face and concussion (these may be rumors, though).
She was too high to consider going for help and took the only remedy she could
think
of…suicide; a gun shot to the head.
There was shock and horror in the porn world when news came that she was dead.
My lord, these Porn execs must have been terrified that their number one moneymaker
was dead. The money! The lost revenue from this commodity! Everyone in the business
was hysterical. Not for her really, but for the business. How would they ever
find yet another Tracy Lords again? This wasn't going to be easy. Think of the
plastic surgery costs. How would they find another? I think it was the same
for poor Kurt. How would they find a new leader with the same disposition, for
the X, Y and Z generations growing in record herd numbers? He knew he was becoming
what he hated -- a media puppet -- though he put up more of a fight. I wondered
was this a trend; were celebrities finally waking up to the reality of their
reluctant, deniable stardom? Was every entertainer joining the NRA? What if
Kurt and Savannah had hooked up? What would that have been like? She was quoted
as saying, “I love sex and I love sex with rockers more than anything
else." It could have happened. Duels at high noon.
Of all the outrageous stories I have heard for reasons to pardon their addiction,
never have I heard of someone doing heroin for ‘stomach' problems.
That seemed a ridiculous excuse... yet I understand because technically, it's
harder to get aid with a Federally Controlled Substance than it is street drugs
like black tar junk. I can think of all the times in my life I have walked down
the streets here growing up in SF, literally having heroin forced upon me, sometimes
up to five offers for me to buy on a single block -- and I wasn't even
looking to buy. But if you need pain medication for a simple injury you find
yourself sitting for hours, say a good 12 to 14, in an emergency room for a bottle
of pain pills that might last for a week, at the longest.
And this is after a
nice long grueling interrogation of you, your personal habits and then finally...
medical history. The guilt and shame some doctors will place upon a person without
knowing the legitimacy of your complaint was unbearable when leaving the E.R.
This makes no sense to me, yet does back up the excuse of Kurt's as to
why he started heroin. My heart goes out to him. After hearing about a difficult
time in a friends life that left them in need of serious medication, with no
one to count on for support, sadly these pills that eased their pain became their
only friends, the only thing they could truly rely on. I remember hearing Kurt
had kept bottles of his pain relievers in a shoebox and talked to them. Said
they were his friends. “Welcome home, I missed you, I love you, old friend," he
was reported to say as he kissed the bottles.
At one point, after finding myself in the same situation as my friend, I found
myself bonding with the medication too. I was relieved to find I wasn't alone
in that. It was common practice to keep the bottles that accumulated throughout
time hidden, in a box as well, afraid of the ‘need' being discovered.
This shame doesn't belong to you, yet it's there… society and the government
placed the stigma a century ago. So all I can say is, I felt for him, I understood
why he did it, if in fact it was suicide. There are a few websites that might
interest those who may be reading this... one for those who find the Kurt incident
humorous: The definitive vocal abnormalities of Nirvana by J. Kocian and S.
Virone (http://ksproul.index.html),
which points out the many groans and grunts found underlying in Kurt's music
that might bring about laughter and sympathy for the man's pain. And for those
who take Kurt's life and story more seriously, there's the website Heroin Times
by the Telesis Foundation.
(Visit www.herointimes.com).
Lana Alaterra
Soon-to-be-famous author
To feel about their life as though it wouldn't be right if it weren't so wrong. Woe!
Craig Clifford
Founder
Baylist.com